The old saying screws for grip strength nails for shear is a good recommendation.
Roofing screws vs nails.
Screws would tend to be slightly thicker than nails because of the threads so you would probably want to watch out for splitting of the wood and might want to require drilling pilot holes if you.
At one time nails were preferred over screws because it was much easier and faster to hammer in nails than to use a manual screwdriver or spiral ratcheting screwdriver e g.
The fact that they have threads means that they will grip the anchoring surface of the roof well.
Not to mention it would take you forever to use screws.
Not a good idea to.
Although screws can be used for framing the building inspector may not agree most building codes still identify 10d and 16d nails as the norm not screws.
The roofing nail is designed to keep the shingles from tearing and blowing off.
You cant use screws to put down shingles.
Screws in steel roofing.
Why screws are likely to be better than nails one of the main reasons why screws are better than nails at metal roof construction is the fact that they tend to hold for much longer.
Use nails for framing and screws for finishing sheathing and subfloor.
Withstanding the test of time.
Robertson first pointed out that by design nails are less brittle than screws which leads to an increase in shear strength for nails.
Nails are also called upon when securing plywood.